• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Litecoin
  • Ethereum
  • Market
While We Wait for Laws, We Need Better Interpretations of Existing Regulation

While We Wait for Laws, We Need Better Interpretations of Existing Regulation

January 4, 2020
White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

March 26, 2022
Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

March 26, 2022
Save on your hotel - hotelscombined.com
ADVERTISEMENT
BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

March 26, 2022
Cryptocurrency Adoption to Grow Significantly This Year in Latam – Bitcoin News

Cryptocurrency Adoption to Grow Significantly This Year in Latam – Bitcoin News

March 26, 2022
Crypto Market Cap Reclaims $2 Trillion as Bitcoin Touched $45K (Weekend Watch)

Crypto Market Cap Reclaims $2 Trillion as Bitcoin Touched $45K (Weekend Watch)

March 26, 2022
3 Metrics to Analyze GameFi Projects

3 Metrics to Analyze GameFi Projects

March 26, 2022
PUBG Developer Krafton Partners With Solana Labs to Build Blockchain Games and Services – Bitcoin News

PUBG Developer Krafton Partners With Solana Labs to Build Blockchain Games and Services – Bitcoin News

March 26, 2022
Coinbase to track off-platform crypto transfers in Canada, Singapore, Japan

Coinbase to track off-platform crypto transfers in Canada, Singapore, Japan

March 26, 2022
Nevada Man Pleads Guilty In $722 Million Bogus Crypto Investment

Nevada Man Pleads Guilty In $722 Million Bogus Crypto Investment

March 26, 2022
Luxury Italian Retailer Michele Franzese Moda Reveals Fashion Brand Accepts Crypto Payments – Bitcoin News

Luxury Italian Retailer Michele Franzese Moda Reveals Fashion Brand Accepts Crypto Payments – Bitcoin News

March 26, 2022
Decentralization, DAOs and the current Web3 concerns

Decentralization, DAOs and the current Web3 concerns

March 26, 2022
Behind the bipartisan crypto bill that’s coming to Congress

Behind the bipartisan crypto bill that’s coming to Congress

March 26, 2022
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us
Sunday, August 14, 2022
Crypto Top News
Save on your hotel - hotelscombined.com
  • Home
  • Altcoin
    Bitcoin at $44.9k as ETFs touch new highs, altcoins continue green rampage

    Bitcoin at $44.9k as ETFs touch new highs, altcoins continue green rampage

    5 “next bitcoins” that weren’t

    5 “next bitcoins” that weren’t

    Where Does Bitcoin Stand With Depleting Dollar Dominance

    Where Does Bitcoin Stand With Depleting Dollar Dominance

    Crypto Corner: The Sports Slice

    Crypto Corner: The Sports Slice

    Polygon (MATIC) suffers network outage sparking a wave of angry users

    Polygon (MATIC) suffers network outage sparking a wave of angry users

    Goldman Sachs Will Now Offer Its Clients Ethereum Funds Via Galaxy Digital

    Goldman Sachs Will Now Offer Its Clients Ethereum Funds Via Galaxy Digital

    Kava adds EVM support to the network with Ethereum co-chain alpha launch

    Kava adds EVM support to the network with Ethereum co-chain alpha launch

    Crypto Corner: The Sports Slice

    Crypto Corner: The Sports Slice

    Fantom Foundation Responds To Andre Conje’s Departure

    Fantom Foundation Responds To Andre Conje’s Departure

    Total amount of Luna tokens staked down 62% from ATH even amid massive price rally

    Total amount of Luna tokens staked down 62% from ATH even amid massive price rally

  • Bitcoin
    White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

    White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

    BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

    BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

    Cryptocurrency Adoption to Grow Significantly This Year in Latam – Bitcoin News

    Cryptocurrency Adoption to Grow Significantly This Year in Latam – Bitcoin News

    PUBG Developer Krafton Partners With Solana Labs to Build Blockchain Games and Services – Bitcoin News

    PUBG Developer Krafton Partners With Solana Labs to Build Blockchain Games and Services – Bitcoin News

    Nevada Man Pleads Guilty In $722 Million Bogus Crypto Investment

    Nevada Man Pleads Guilty In $722 Million Bogus Crypto Investment

    Luxury Italian Retailer Michele Franzese Moda Reveals Fashion Brand Accepts Crypto Payments – Bitcoin News

    Luxury Italian Retailer Michele Franzese Moda Reveals Fashion Brand Accepts Crypto Payments – Bitcoin News

    APENFT Marketplace Makes NFT Drops in the TRON Ecosystem Accessible – Press release Bitcoin News

    APENFT Marketplace Makes NFT Drops in the TRON Ecosystem Accessible – Press release Bitcoin News

    DOJ Charges Two People in Million-Dollar Scheme to Defraud Investors – Regulation Bitcoin News

    DOJ Charges Two People in Million-Dollar Scheme to Defraud Investors – Regulation Bitcoin News

    After years of doubts and concerns, it is finally Bitcoin’s time to shine

    After years of doubts and concerns, it is finally Bitcoin’s time to shine

  • Cryptocurrency
    • Ethereum
    • Litecoin
  • Blockchain
    Decentralization, DAOs and the current Web3 concerns

    Decentralization, DAOs and the current Web3 concerns

    MIT adds the Bank of England to its stable of CBDC digital currency research partners

    MIT adds the Bank of England to its stable of CBDC digital currency research partners

    Learn about Web3 and how it aims to transform internet services

    Learn about Web3 and how it aims to transform internet services

    European crypto regulatory framework goes to three-way consideration without PoW ban

    European crypto regulatory framework goes to three-way consideration without PoW ban

    Jamaica’s central bank digital currency and the problems it hopes to solve

    Jamaica’s central bank digital currency and the problems it hopes to solve

    LG Electronics adds blockchain and crypto as new areas of business

    LG Electronics adds blockchain and crypto as new areas of business

    Powers On… Biden accepts blockchain technology, recognizes its benefits and pushes for adoption – Cointelegraph Magazine

    Powers On… Biden accepts blockchain technology, recognizes its benefits and pushes for adoption – Cointelegraph Magazine

    IOSCO says DeFi is quickly evolving and ‘cloning financial markets’

    IOSCO says DeFi is quickly evolving and ‘cloning financial markets’

    Stargate Finance attracts $1.9B in six days

    Stargate Finance attracts $1.9B in six days

  • Regulation
    Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

    Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

    Coinbase to track off-platform crypto transfers in Canada, Singapore, Japan

    Coinbase to track off-platform crypto transfers in Canada, Singapore, Japan

    Behind the bipartisan crypto bill that’s coming to Congress

    Behind the bipartisan crypto bill that’s coming to Congress

    US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen says upcoming crypto regulations will nourish healthy innovation

    US Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen says upcoming crypto regulations will nourish healthy innovation

    Secretary Yellen recognizes ‘benefits of crypto’ despite lingering skepticism

    Secretary Yellen recognizes ‘benefits of crypto’ despite lingering skepticism

    Crypto tax policy framework passes India’s parliament despite pushback from lawmakers

    Crypto tax policy framework passes India’s parliament despite pushback from lawmakers

    US senators Lummis, Gillibrand reveal working on bipartisan crypto legislation

    US senators Lummis, Gillibrand reveal working on bipartisan crypto legislation

    Finally, a proof of work ban is off the table in Europe

    Finally, a proof of work ban is off the table in Europe

    Korean crypto exchanges are now in compliance with the Travel Rule

    Korean crypto exchanges are now in compliance with the Travel Rule

  • Market
    3 Metrics to Analyze GameFi Projects

    3 Metrics to Analyze GameFi Projects

    Coinbase to Label Some Assets as ‘Experimental’ In Bid to Boost Transparency

    Coinbase to Require Recipient Information for Crypto Transfers From Users in Canada, Singapore and Japan

    ‘We Have Entered a Period of Pain,’ Says WazirX CEO of India’s New Tax Laws

    ‘We Have Entered a Period of Pain,’ Says WazirX CEO of India’s New Tax Laws

    White House Wants Public Comments on Crypto’s Energy Use and Environmental Impact

    White House Wants Public Comments on Crypto’s Energy Use and Environmental Impact

    Greener Bitcoin Mining Could Be China’s ‘Trillion-Dollar Present’ to the US

    Greener Bitcoin Mining Could Be China’s ‘Trillion-Dollar Present’ to the US

    Bitcoin Tops $44K Amid Rumors of Terra's LFG Accumulating BTC

    Bitcoin supera los $44.000 entre rumores de compra de BTC por parte de Fundación Terra

    Bitcoin Outperforms as Crypto Bulls Take a Breather

    Bitcoin Outperforms as Crypto Bulls Take a Breather

    4 Reasons Why Bitcoiners Should Pass on El Salvador’s Bitcoin Bond

    4 Reasons Why Bitcoiners Should Pass on El Salvador’s Bitcoin Bond

    Bitcoin Faces Initial Resistance at $46K; Support at $42K

    Bitcoin Faces Initial Resistance at $46K; Support at $42K

  • Prices
  • ICO
  • Travel Websites
No Result
View All Result
Crypto Top News
No Result
View All Result
Home Market

While We Wait for Laws, We Need Better Interpretations of Existing Regulation

by Admin
January 4, 2020
in Market
0
While We Wait for Laws, We Need Better Interpretations of Existing Regulation


This post is part of CoinDesk’s 2019 Year in Review, a collection of 100 op-eds, interviews and takes on the state of blockchain and the world. William Mougayar is the author of “The Business Blockchain,” producer of the Token Summit, and a venture investor and advisor.

When it comes to US cryptocurrency regulation, one school of thought says it’s worth waiting for Congressional action to deliver a friendlier regulatory environment, resulting in a re-energized blockchain market and underlying entrepreneurial activity.

Another viewpoint, which I share, says Congress provides no magic pill or panacea due to the long time it takes to pass new acts and bills. Instead, we need to seek modernized interpretations of current regulation, especially securities laws under the SEC’s purview.

Few New Acts Since 1933

There is little hope in seeing a new cryptocurrency or blockchain-related act emerge from the House or Senate in the next 12 months, if not longer. This is election year, so attention span is elsewhere. Also, we need to factor in the ongoing distractions on omnipresent geopolitical, economic or social agenda items within the United States and beyond. The blockchain faces all of these preceding and competing priorities.

In eight decades of history, the SEC has been moved by a relatively small number of new pieces of legislation. From the independent agency’s web site: the Securities Act of 1933; the Securities Exchange Act of 1934; the Trust Indenture Act of 1939;Investment Company Act of 1940; the Investment Advisers Act of 1940; the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002; the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010; and the Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act of 2012.

Since the Securities Act of 1933, there have been only seven other acts, four of which came before 1940, followed by three more after 2002, and none for more than 60 years in between. That’s an average of one act per decade. Based on this, it is hard to imagine a dedicated financial blockchain act emerging in 2020.

There is a common pattern to these acts: they tend to be reactionary outcomes to significant incidents. The Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 were born of the severity of abuses that led to the crash of 1929. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 was prompted by the Enron scandal. The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010 was concocted in the aftermath of the 2008 global financial crisis.

Libra

The Facebook-Libra mid-2019 announcement caused a blip in the political attention scale. After Congressional Hearings July-October, the House of Representatives proposed a new Bill to establish the treatment of managed stablecoins under the 1933 Securities Act, titled “Stablecoins Are Securities Act of 2019.” This bill was squarely aimed to limit the wingspan of the Libra project. However, it faced immediate criticism. It was rushed and resulted in also being a potential threat to other existing stablecoins. This proposed bill was throwing the baby with the bathwater.

Since 2013, there have been close to 100 diverse blockchain or FinTech related legislative proposals, not including uniform state bills (Source: Digital Asset Affairs). The five that passed mentioned blockchain in minor ways. In fact, proposed bills have an average success rate of 2-5%. There is a lack of support required to muscle in legislative change, despite the valiant efforts of industry organizations such as the Coin Center, Blockchain Association and Digital Chamber of Commerce. Bills and acts are forever dying on the proverbial Capitol Hill vine.

Why No Rulemaking for Blockchain?

A quick scan of the SEC’s Rulemaking Index for 2019 points to a long list of 36 Proposed or Final Rules for amending or updating a variety of activities on topics such as Accredited Investor Definition, Cross-Border Applications for Security-Based Swap Requirements, Exemptions from the Proxy Rules for Proxy Voting Advice, Payment Methods Modernization, Modernization of Regulation S-K items, and several other subjects.

There is a lack of support required to muscle in legislative change.

These were very specific and prescriptive updates, some of them going as far as including updates to the EDGAR filing manual.

The sad irony of this finding is two-fold. First, none of these rulemaking updates included anything about blockchain or cryptocurrency. Second, this activity seemingly took place without an attachment to new legislation, i.e. the SEC acted on their own, based on market feedback and the desire to continuously modernize their oversight processes.

Sadly, the SEC has not shown a similar degree of willingness to create modern interpretations for cryptocurrency with the same vigor and intensity they have given other aspects of the securities laws.

Nothing new here

Instead, the SEC resorted to occasionally releasing haphazard guidance statements (that were not even consistent with each other), initiating dozens of investigations, and launching a few lawsuits or enforcement actions. All and all, the SEC gradually left the industry craving for more clarity or prescriptive guidelines that could have taken into account the innovative implications of token-based projects who were gasping for air and clamoring to see the light of day under a friendlier regulatory climate.

Regrettably, no added insight, clarity or lessons have resulted from this enforcement-led strategy and agenda. The SEC kept implying there was nothing new here, that the existing securities laws were good enough, and that companies should line-up to follow these rules.

But companies did not line up to spend $2M in legal fees to follow a Reg A+ process, as the SEC might have wished. Instead, the majority of US-based projects either folded their ambitions or fled to more clement international jurisdictions.

Companies did not line up to spend $2M in legal fees to follow a Reg A+ process.

We learned in 2019 that Reg A+ is not the model. Only two companies filed under that process (Blockstack and YouNow); only Blockstack has launched an offering. Fast-forward to now and Blockstack’s token value is trading at one-third of its offering price, having lost money for consumers who were investors.

Ironically, filing under the SEC rules was an argument used by the SEC to pinpoint the lowering of risks and losses. This shows that even if you followed the (expensive) SEC regulatory process, consumers would not be immune to potentially losing their money. Of course there are many other success factors in play, but the SEC is not so attuned to these nuances. This also suggests that cryptocurrency and blockchain technology deserve their own share of rulemaking.

Is Hester Peirce Our Only Hope?

It would be wrong to assume that everyone at the SEC is oblivious about the blockchain. Commissioner Hester Peirce has been a breath of fresh air, and perhaps the only visible hope that the SEC might one day improve their positions.

Through her many speeches, Commissioner Peirce has given the industry hope and a glimpse of what a blockchain-friendly SEC could be doing.

For example, this short passage from a recent speech entitled Broken Windows: Remarks before the 51st Annual Institute on Securities Regulation, sums up the somber reality we are in:

“I am concerned about how the SEC has regulated this space because I believe our lack of a workable regulatory framework has hindered innovation and growth. The only guidance out of the SEC is a parade of enforcement actions and a set of staff guidance documents and staff no-action letters…Of particular concern is that these enforcement actions and guidance pieces, taken together, offer no clear path for a functioning token network to emerge.”

What The SEC Could Have Done

Many individuals in the blockchain industry would rejoice at the thought of Hester Peirce becoming the next SEC Chair, along with the anticipation that a change of leadership would usher a positive shift in US regulatory strategy.

While we shouldn’t hold our breath for new Congressional action on cryptocurrencies. But, while we are still stuck with a complacent SEC stance, we could dream a little about what a better regulatory climate for cryptocurrency could have looked like.

Here is a list of potential actions that could have been undertaken by the SEC:

  • Introduce new filing processes with defined disclosure criteria and details tailored for blockchain technology projects.
  • Institute a Safe Harbor policy with specific terms and conditions to relieve qualified projects from the burden of unnecessary compliance requirements.
  • Restrict the amounts to be raised during token offerings as a way to limit the potential downsides.
  • Provide more prescriptive and precise guidance that entrepreneurs can apply without guesswork and with less legal resources.

As well as making concrete action, the SEC needs to answer two vexing, but fundamental questions, which it mostly avoids:

Why are there no modernized rulemaking updates for cryptocurrency and blockchain technology?

Why are the recommendations and ideas behind many of Hester Peirce’s speeches not being followed up by the SEC?

The blockchain novelty aspect is starring the SEC in the eye, but they remain in a state of denial that something is new here.

The world was expecting the US to lead on regulatory guidance for blockchain technology, but the SEC has not answered the challenge. Instead, we are faced with a panoply of local regulatory positions from 130 countries that are as diverse as their peoples, while being difficult to reconcile for the average entrepreneur who must think global.

There is no point “HODLing” hope for new Congressional legislation, but we can wish for a new chapter of more enlightened SEC leadership.

Disclosure Read More

The leader in blockchain news, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups.





Source link

728*90
ADVERTISEMENT
300*250
ADVERTISEMENT
Admin

Admin

300*250
ADVERTISEMENT
300*250
ADVERTISEMENT
300*250
ADVERTISEMENT
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Circle Captures $440 Million in Financing, Rumors of SPAC Deal Follow – Finance Bitcoin News

Circle Captures $440 Million in Financing, Rumors of SPAC Deal Follow – Finance Bitcoin News

May 29, 2021
Grayscale Parent Company to Purchase Ethereum Classic Trust Shares Worth $50 Million

Grayscale Parent Company to Purchase Ethereum Classic Trust Shares Worth $50 Million

June 22, 2021
Spain’s Largest Asset Managers Still Reluctant to Invest in Cryptocurrencies – News Bitcoin News

Spain’s Largest Asset Managers Still Reluctant to Invest in Cryptocurrencies – News Bitcoin News

May 29, 2021
White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

0
Ethereum Plunges 10% in 48 hours

Ethereum Plunges 10% in 48 hours

0
Public vs Private Blockchain | Ernst & Young’s New Blockchain Prototype

Public vs Private Blockchain | Ernst & Young’s New Blockchain Prototype

0
White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

White House office seeks public opinion on crypto-climate implications

March 26, 2022
Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

Love it or hate it, crypto’s vibe shift is now imminent

March 26, 2022
BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

BTC, ETH Begin Weekend Close to Key Resistance Levels – Market Updates Bitcoin News

March 26, 2022
Crypto Top News

Copyright © 2019 cryptotopnews.com

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Newsletter
  • Contact Us

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Altcoin
  • Bitcoin
  • Cryptocurrency
    • Ethereum
    • Litecoin
  • Blockchain
  • Regulation
  • Market
  • Prices
  • ICO
  • Travel Websites

Copyright © 2019 cryptotopnews.com

  • bitcoinBitcoin (BTC) $ 24,574.00
  • ethereumEthereum (ETH) $ 1,991.53
  • tetherTether (USDT) $ 1.00
  • usd-coinUSD Coin (USDC) $ 1.00
  • bnbBNB (BNB) $ 327.05
  • cardanoCardano (ADA) $ 0.582739
  • xrpXRP (XRP) $ 0.386630
  • binance-usdBinance USD (BUSD) $ 0.998717
  • solanaSolana (SOL) $ 46.78
  • polkadotPolkadot (DOT) $ 9.37